A Sun Lounger Lawsuit Has Cruisers Asking One Big Question: Could Cruise Lines Be Next?

Pool deck chair hogs are already one of cruising’s most familiar little battles. Towels on loungers. Flip-flops holding prime real estate. Not a single person actually sitting there.

Now, a recent court case in Germany has made that everyday vacation annoyance feel a little more serious.

A German tourist was awarded €986.70 after arguing that his family couldn’t properly use the pool loungers during a 2024 package holiday in Kos, Greece, because other guests kept reserving them with towels. The case involved a hotel resort and tour operator, not a cruise line, but the issue will sound familiar to cruise passengers: there was a rule against reserving loungers, and the traveler said it wasn’t properly enforced.

That raises an obvious question. If cruise lines already have policies against chair hogging, could they face more pressure to enforce them?

This doesn’t mean cruise lines are suddenly headed for court over every towel left on a lounger. But it does put a fresh spotlight on one of the most common pool deck complaints at sea.

What Happened in the Sun Lounger Lawsuit

The lawsuit centered on a package holiday to Kos, Greece, in August 2024. The man had traveled with his family and said the pool area became a daily frustration.

He reportedly tried to find four loungers early in the morning, searching for around 20 minutes from as early as 6 a.m. Even then, he said he couldn’t get suitable seats because other guests had already claimed them with towels.

This wasn’t presented as one unlucky afternoon by the pool. The complaint was about a repeated issue across the trip. The hotel reportedly had a rule against reserving loungers this way, but the tourist argued it wasn’t being properly enforced.

The Hanover District Court awarded him €986.70, which is roughly $1,150 USD. Reports said his holiday package cost €7,186, or about $8,371 USD, meaning the refund came to around 14% of the total trip cost.

The court did not say every guest must have a lounger at all times. The focus was whether the hotel and tour operator had a fair system for stopping loungers from being blocked for long periods.

No cruise line was involved in the case. Still, the basic complaint will sound very familiar to anyone who has walked around a pool deck on a sea day, staring at rows of “reserved” chairs with nobody actually sitting in them.

Why This Case Is Getting Attention

The story has traveled beyond hotel resorts because it touches on a common vacation frustration.

A lounger by the pool may not be the whole point of a trip, but for many people, it’s part of the experience they paid for. On a cruise, that can feel even more noticeable on sea days, when thousands of passengers are on the ship at the same time and outdoor space becomes prime real estate.

The German court’s decision doesn’t create a new rule for cruise ships. It also doesn’t mean passengers can automatically sue a cruise line if they don’t get a chair by the pool.

But it does raise a fair question: if a company has a clear policy against reserving chairs and then doesn’t enforce it, could that become more than just a customer service issue?

Chair Hogging Is Already a Familiar Cruise Problem

Cruise passengers have been complaining about chair hogging for years.

The usual pattern is easy to spot. Someone heads to the pool deck early, drops a towel, book, hat, sunscreen bottle, or pair of flip-flops on a lounger, then disappears. Sometimes they’re gone for breakfast. Sometimes they’re gone for hours.

Meanwhile, other guests circle the deck looking for a seat, often while plenty of “claimed” chairs sit empty.

Most passengers understand that leaving your chair briefly is normal. Nobody expects a guest to lose their spot because they went to grab a drink, take a quick dip, or use the restroom.

The problem is when a chair is treated like private property for half the day.

Related Reading: 14 Cruise Habits That Annoy Everyone (and How to Avoid Them)

What Cruise Lines Currently Say About Reserved Chairs

Most major cruise lines already have rules about this, even if guests don’t always see them applied the same way on every sailing.

Carnival Cruise Line has one of the clearest systems. Its “ChairShare Team” monitors loungers, and if a chair appears to be empty but has belongings on it, crew members can place a timed sticker on the chair. If the chair is still empty after 40 minutes, the belongings are removed and held for safekeeping.

Royal Caribbean also says pool deck chairs are available on a first-come, first-served basis and cannot be reserved. Its policy says that if a pool chair is left unattended for more than 30 minutes with no sign of the guest returning, crew may remove the belongings and place them in lost and found.

The rules are fairly clear. The harder part is making sure passengers see them enforced consistently.

The Bigger Issue Is Enforcement

This is where cruise lines face a tricky balance.

If crew members remove items too quickly, passengers may get upset. If they don’t remove them at all, other passengers get upset. Either way, someone is probably going to complain.

There’s also the matter of personal belongings. Even if the policy allows crew to move unattended items, staff may still be careful about handling phones, bags, shoes, books, or anything else left behind. A missing item can turn a chair dispute into a much bigger headache.

That may explain why enforcement can feel uneven. On some ships, crew actively sticker chairs and clear abandoned loungers. On others, passengers may feel like the rule exists mostly as a sign near the pool.

And that’s the point this lawsuit brings into focus. If a rule exists but guests feel it isn’t being enforced, the frustration can shift from “other passengers are being inconsiderate” to “the company isn’t managing the space fairly.”

Could Cruise Lines Actually be Sued Over Chair Hogs?

In theory, almost anything can lead to a lawsuit. Whether it succeeds is a very different question.

A cruise case would likely depend on the cruise contract, where the case is filed, what the cruise line promised, what happened onboard, and whether the passenger could show that the issue seriously affected their trip.

That’s a high bar.

Cruise lines also don’t generally promise every passenger a poolside lounger whenever they want one. Ships are shared spaces, and popular areas are always going to fill up at busy times.

The German ruling is still worth noting because it focused on a repeated issue, a policy that allegedly wasn’t enforced, and whether the vacation experience fell short of what had reasonably been sold.

That doesn’t transfer neatly onto cruise ships, especially under different legal systems. Still, it could make travel companies think harder about how clearly they write their rules and how often they apply them.

What Passengers Can Do Without Causing a Scene

For passengers, the best move is not to start moving someone else’s belongings.

That might be tempting after the third lap around the pool deck, but it can easily turn into an argument. It’s better to speak with a crew member and ask whether the ship’s chair policy can be applied.

The bigger takeaway is simple: don’t turn a chair hog problem into a passenger-versus-passenger fight. Use the ship’s own rules, keep it polite, and let the crew handle it.

For more practical ways to deal with this onboard, read: 7 Ways to Beat the Poolside Chair Hogs on Your Next Cruise.

What This Could Mean for Future Cruises

This one court case doesn’t mean cruise lines are suddenly facing a wave of chair hog lawsuits.

But it does add pressure to a conversation that was already happening. Passengers want pool deck rules that are clear, fair, and enforced. Cruise lines want to avoid confrontations, complaints, and guest frustration.

The simplest fix may not be new rules. It may be more consistent use of the rules already in place.

Chair hogging might sound like a small issue, but on a packed sea day, it can shape how guests feel about the whole cruise. And when vacation time and money are involved, even a pool chair can become a much bigger deal than it looks.

You Might Also Like…