Loyal Cruisers Left Frustrated as Royal Caribbean Shifts to Shorter Sailings

Many cruisers fondly remember stepping aboard one of Royal Caribbean’s iconic Oasis-class ships for the first time, dazzled by the sheer scale and endless possibilities onboard. Yet, imagine now having only a brief window of three to five days to experience everything these ships have to offer.

Royal Caribbean’s decision to offer shorter sailings on its famed mega-ships has sparked a lively discussion among cruise enthusiasts, raising a question: Is this a bold innovation or a strategic misstep?

Loyal Cruisers Speak Out

Frequent cruisers have expressed a variety of perspectives regarding shorter sailings. Some seasoned passengers argue these enormous vessels simply cannot be thoroughly enjoyed in just a few days.

One cruiser recalled their experience vividly: “Our first cruise was on Allure of the Seas, and even seven days wasn’t enough to see everything. We had to book another cruise just to experience it all.” Another cruiser agreed, asserting, “These ships really need at least five to six nights.”

Others express frustration over the repetitive itineraries, often limited to the Bahamas and Royal Caribbean’s private island, Perfect Day at CocoCay. Many longtime cruisers feel these routes lack the sense of exploration traditionally expected from cruising.

Furthermore, the affordability of booking back-to-back shorter cruises remains a significant concern. One cruiser summed up their disappointment succinctly: “I don’t like this trend—it leaves me no affordable options for larger ships.”

Additionally, some passengers express dissatisfaction with the party-centric atmosphere prevalent on shorter cruises, with one cruiser candidly stating, “Shorter cruises equal party ship. Don’t like it, will never go on them!”

Practical issues like travel logistics and cost have also been raised, particularly by those living farther away. As a cruiser from the West Coast noted, “I wouldn’t fly all the way to Florida just for a short cruise.”

The Strategic Shift Explained

Despite the mixed reactions, Royal Caribbean’s pivot to shorter sailings is rooted in solid business reasoning. Traditionally, older ships were used for short cruises, but Royal Caribbean has intentionally chosen its newest, most feature-rich Oasis-class vessels to stand out against competitors.

Short cruises now serve as an enticing introduction to cruising for first-timers, allowing them to experience the best of cruising without a significant time or financial commitment.

Supporting this strategy, the Cruise Line Industry Association (CLIA) reports that only around 15% of the U.S. population has experienced cruising, representing an enormous market opportunity.

Short cruises frequently sell out quickly, command higher per-night rates, and strongly appeal to younger travellers who value short, flexible escapes compatible with their busy lives.

Historical Context and Future Trends

This strategic move is not unprecedented. Historically, Royal Caribbean has regularly adjusted ship deployments in response to changing market trends and demands. Previously, older vessels, such as the Voyager and Freedom-class ships, fulfilled these short itineraries.

The current deployment of Oasis-class ships to short cruises reflects another stage in this evolving strategy. Given this cyclical nature, it’s possible the trend will shift again in the future.

Market Reactions and Future Considerations

The current shift has already prompted some loyal cruisers to reconsider their cruise preferences. One cruiser remarked, “I’m definitely not a fan because I don’t want to sail on older ships and can’t justify the expense of Icon-class ships. We’re already looking at other cruise lines.”

On the other hand, busy professionals appreciate the convenience, with one commenter noting, “As a full-time worker, a quick three-night cruise on a big ship allows me to recharge without taking vacation days.”

The future of Royal Caribbean’s short-cruise strategy remains uncertain, with clear trade-offs between profitability, customer satisfaction, and market expansion. As loyalists weigh alternatives and newcomers explore these short voyages, industry observers and cruise fans will closely watch how this controversial decision unfolds.

You Might Like to Read

• Royal Caribbean Ships Ranked Best To Worst (Rated By Reviews)
• 7 Things Royal Caribbean Does Better Than Other Cruise Lines
• 7 Things to Consider When Cruising on Royal Caribbean’s Older Ships