Imagine this: you’re lounging on the deck of a cruise ship, the sun shining, the sea breeze in your hair, and your dog wagging their tail beside you. Sounds idyllic, right? Well, Margaritaville at Sea thinks so, as they’re introducing a dog-friendly cruise in 2026. But not everyone is thrilled about the idea.
In partnership with Cruise Tails and Expedia Cruises of West Orlando, this unique voyage will welcome up to 250 dogs and their owners aboard the Islander, sailing from Port Tampa Bay. While the details, like the itinerary and exact date, are still being finalised, a waitlist for dog-loving travellers opened in December 2024.
For dog owners, this is groundbreaking. Steve Matzke, the Cruise Tails Captain, said: “For years, I missed out on family reunion cruises because I wouldn’t leave my Yorkie, Louis, behind. I want to change that for myself and other dog lovers.”
Activities on board will include costume contests, parades, dog shows, and even pampering sessions like puppy massages. There’ll also be doggy splash zones and private balcony relief areas for those staying in pet-friendly staterooms.
Why Some People Are Against the Idea of Dog-Friendly Cruises
The idea of a dog-friendly cruise has divided opinions, with some people eagerly booking their spots while others are raising serious concerns. Let’s face it: not everyone wants to share their holiday with barking, shedding, or excitable furry friends. Here are some of the reasons why:
1. Noise Issues
The thought of constant barking and whining has also sparked concern. While not all dogs are noisy, having 250 onboard could lead to a lot of interruptions, especially in communal areas. And let’s be honest—dogs tend to bark more when other dogs set them off. For some, the idea of losing the peaceful cruise atmosphere to a canine choir is a dealbreaker.
2. Poop Patrol Problems
Who’s responsible for cleaning up after the dogs? While owners are expected to manage their pets, some worry that not all will stick to the rules, leaving extra work for the crew and unpleasant surprises for other passengers.
Cruise Tails has stated that dogs won’t be allowed on pool decks to keep those areas clean, but maintaining hygiene in shared spaces will still be a major challenge.
3. Overboard Fears
Some people, especially those who love water, worry about dogs jumping overboard. While cruise railings are high enough to prevent most accidents, imagining curious pups making an unexpected dive into the ocean is still a source of anxiety.
4. Hygiene Concerns
One of the biggest complaints is about hygiene. Critics worry that dog hair, messes, and even the possibility of fleas could turn the ship into a less-than-pleasant environment. Margaritaville at Sea has promised private relief areas for each dog on stateroom balconies and additional dog toilets around the ship, but many believe extra cleaning will be inevitable.
5. Allergies and Phobias
Passengers with dog allergies or a fear of dogs have voiced concerns about sharing spaces with so many pets. While these cruises will be optional, and there are still plenty of dog-free sailings available, some feel excluded from this growing trend.
6. Stress on the Dogs
It’s not just people who might struggle on a cruise—dogs could too. Loud noises, unfamiliar surroundings, and the motion of the ship can be stressful for animals, especially those not used to travelling. Ultimately, it will be up to each owner to decide whether their dog is suited for this type of holiday.
7. Poorly Trained Pets
Not all dogs are well-behaved. Some passengers worry about encountering untrained or unsocialised dogs, which could lead to accidents, fights, or general chaos. However, as some have pointed out, humans aren’t always the most well-behaved passengers either!
8. Limited Options for Non-Dog Lovers
Some passengers feel that cruises should cater to everyone, and they worry that the rise of dog-friendly cruises could reduce options for pet-free getaways. With over 300 ships available, there’s no sign of that happening anytime soon, but the debate continues.
9. Cabin Chaos
What happens when owners leave their dogs in the cabin to go on excursions? Critics fear barking, damage to furniture, and general mischief from unsupervised pets. With Margaritaville at Sea offering shorter cruises, it’s possible there won’t be many port stops, or the stops will allow dogs to disembark for a break, but this remains a concern for some.
10. Complex Logistics
From potty areas to veterinary care, accommodating 250 dogs is no small feat. Critics question whether the cruise line can handle the extra challenges while still providing a smooth experience for human passengers.
Rules to Keep Things Ship-Shape
To keep things in check, there will be rules. Dogs must be vaccinated and accompanied by a vet-certified health certificate and will be restricted to specific pet-friendly areas. They’ll need to stay on leads in public, and their families will be assigned a “Pet Butler” to maintain cleanliness and comfort. Dogs won’t be allowed in restaurants, casinos, pool areas, or the spa.
Even with these precautions, the idea has sparked debate. On one hand, it’s a dream come true for dog owners, giving them the chance to travel with their entire “family.” On the other, some argue it’s impractical and unfair to other passengers who might prefer a traditional, dog-free cruise.
A Bold Experiment or a Future Trend?
Whether you love the idea or loathe it, it’s certainly sparking conversation. If this November 2025 voyage is a success, there are already talks of a second dog-friendly cruise in early 2026.
So, what do you think? Is this a genius way to include our pets in our adventures, or does it sound like a cruise ship-sized headache? Let me know your thoughts in the comments!
Today’s Top Cruise Deals
See today’s best deals from ALL travel agents
You Might Also Like…
Thanks for reading!
I'm Hannah and I've been cruising for as long as I can remember.
If you enjoy my cruise tips, be sure to follow me on social media for more...
Where can I find the waitlist?
I would contact Cruise Tails directly: https://www.cruisetails.com/details
My thoughts? Marnie doesn’t like dogs! 😂
Here’s the thing: people who are going to do this are willing to spend the money to take their dog along. And these kind of people tend to be very responsible pet owners. I highly doubt they will allow dogs to run free anywhere. And if there is a playground available, I would certainly hope it is fully fenced extremely high.
As for other issues, you point out like allergies, and people getting annoyed, I would assume they’re going to restrict the pet owners to certain floors of the ship where they won’t bother people.
And I would certainly hope they would make any potential guests aware well in advance that this cruise is going to be dog friendly. Anyone who doesn’t like dogs or fairs that it could be a disaster — they can cruise another time on another ship!
I think that sounds fantastic with the right safeguards in place.
I imagine the staff would find pets to be far more manageable than people.
Concern over other non-dog people’s reation is kind of silly. If you don’t want to be around dogs, don’t go on a dog friendly cruise.
Personally, our issue would be getting our golden to the cruise port. I hope my girl never has to be in a cargo hold again, it’s far too stressful!
This is a wonderful idea, but it’s not one we would take advantage of with our girl. I’m sure there are plenty of people who would love it.
Hi! Thank you for the article. I’ve been waiting for a cruise line to finally acknowledge a pet friendly cruise. There are a lot of us pet parents that won’t consider a cruise because we don’t want to leave our fur babies. There are a few cruise lines that do allow pets, but they have to remain kenneled below and with only certain visiting hours for the owners. Not an option for most pet owners. If pet owners are going to go through the trouble of taking their pets on a cruise, I would hope they would also follow the rules and guidelines as well as be respectful. Also, if there are guests who are not in favor of being around pets, perhaps a different cruise would be a better option.