Carnival vs MSC: Which Cruise Line Should You Choose?

Are you trying to decide whether to go on a cruise with Carnival or MSC? Both have earned a place in the hearts of cruisers around the world and are giants in the cruise industry. However, if you’re trying to decide which one to go on, it’s worth taking the time to compare the differences and see which one suits you best.

Both Carnival and MSC Cruises have their unique selling points. While Carnival is highly rated for its vibrant culture, MSC Cruises is known for its low fares and good value for money. Deciding between Carnival and MSC comes down to personal preference and what you want on a cruise. So, in this blog post, I’ll break down the details you need to help you decide which cruise line is for you.

Comparing Carnival and MSC’s Fleet

When it comes to the fleet, both Carnival and MSC boast impressive ships with unique features. Carnival is known for its fun-filled atmosphere and vast array of entertainment options.

On the other hand, MSC, with its European charm, offers a more sophisticated experience. There’s a lot to consider, from their new ships to the range of cabin options. Let’s start by exploring Carnival’s fleet.

Carnival’s Fleet

Carnival boasts a fleet of 25 ships, with new ships planned to be added to the fleet over the next few years. Each ship presents a unique blend of entertainment and relaxation, promising a fun-filled cruise vacation. Carnival’s ships feature a festive atmosphere, ensuring you have a great time from the moment you step onboard.

However, one of the standout features of Carnival’s fleet is the variety of entertainment options. There’s something for everyone, from live shows, rollercoasters and parties to wellness activities and sports facilities. So, whether you’re looking for a high-energy vacation or a relaxed getaway, Carnival has got you covered.

Recommended reading: Best & Worst Carnival Cruise Ships (Ranked By Reviews)

MSC’s Fleet

MSC’s fleet stands out with 23 ships (and more to come) that sail across the globe. Each cruise, designed with a modern touch, offers a blend of Mediterranean style and a tinge of international sophistication. This European charm is evident in each MSC ship’s architecture and décor, setting it apart from Carnival.

Aside from the aesthetic appeal, MSC’s fleet boasts a range of entertainment options. From Broadway-style shows to room service that rivals the best on land, their ships are designed to provide a great cruising experience.

Key Takeaway:

Carnival’s fleet, known for its festive atmosphere and diverse entertainment options, offers a fun and energetic cruise experience across its ships, while MSC’s fleet is characterized by European elegance and modern sophistication, providing a more refined experience with a variety of entertainment and high-quality services.

The Itineraries: Carnival vs MSC

When it comes to itineraries, both Carnival and MSC have plenty to offer. However, the distinction lies in the destinations they cover and the number of itineraries they provide.

Carnival’s Destinations

Carnival Cruise Line offers a variety of cruise durations, ranging from two to 31 days, departing from numerous major cities across the globe, including key locations in the United States and Sydney, Australia.

Carnival’s forte lies in their Caribbean cruises, which often start in Miami and have become synonymous with the brand. However, they offer cruises from the breathtaking beauty of Alaska to the exotic locales of Mexico and The Bahamas, Carnival covers an impressive array of destinations. Moreover, Carnival Cruise Line Australia, with its two ships, offers cruises from Sydney and Brisbane to New Zealand and the Pacific Islands.

MSC’s Destinations

MSC Cruises offers a diverse range of destinations that cater to a variety of interests. Their itineraries include the Mediterranean, covering the Adriatic, Eastern, and Western regions, and extend to Spain, the Canary Islands, Portugal, and Corsica. Beyond Europe, MSC Cruises features routes to Egypt, the Red Sea, and Saudi Arabia, as well as South America, the Emirates, and North America.

Additional destinations include the Nordics, Greenland, the Caribbean with the Bahamas and Ocean Cay MSC Marine Reserve, Asia, South Africa, and the Seychelles, providing a comprehensive selection for travelers.

Key Takeaway:

While Carnival excels with its varied duration cruises and a focus on Caribbean destinations, also offering routes from Alaska to the Pacific Islands, MSC distinguishes itself with a wide-ranging selection of destinations, including the Mediterranean, the Middle East and South America.

Activities Offered

If you’re like me and you’re not just concerned with the destination, but the activities available on the ship are just as important. Here’s what Carnival and MSC ships have to offer:

Carnival’s Activities

On Carnival ships, there are loads of entertainment options designed to keep everyone from older kids to adults engaged, but the exact lineup depends heavily on the ship. Some newer ships feature attractions like an IMAX theater or a ropes course, while the Excel‑class ships (Mardi Gras, Carnival Celebration, and Carnival Jubilee) even have BOLT, the first roller coaster at sea, along with large waterparks and sports areas.

For example, aboard Carnival’s Mardi Gras, guests can indulge in a range of activities: The Ultimate Playground boasts the first roller coaster at sea, BOLT, alongside a ropes course, zip line, and waterslides. Evening entertainment thrives with unique offerings like the Family Feud game show in the Mardi Gras Theater and a variety of live music and performances in the Grand Atrium.

For relaxation and rejuvenation, the Cloud 9 spa complex features a vast array of treatments, a Thalassotherapy pool, and a serene Thermal Suite, ensuring a balance of excitement and tranquillity during the cruise.

During the cruise, you can also expect to see some game shows hosted by the crew. You can even participate in Carnival’s version of Deal or No Deal and win prizes. There are also parties held in some of the upper decks, so if you’re looking for a dance partner, you’re sure to find one there.

You can also visit the spa to unwind after all the fun or head up to the Serenity Adults-Only Deck to get some peace, sun, and relaxation. Whatever mood you’re in, there’s always something to accommodate you on a Carnival Cruise.

Related reading: Which is the best carnival ship for kids?

MSC’s Activities

MSC sells its standard cabins under three main “Experiences” – Bella, Fantastica, and Aurea – which are fare types that change your perks, cabin location options and some inclusions, rather than limiting which activities you can do. Bella is the entry level, Fantastica adds better cabin locations and flexibility, and Aurea layers on extra perks such as priority boarding, spa access and an exclusive sun deck on many ships.

For ultimate luxury, MSC’s Yacht Club offers private suites with butler service, exclusive pools and concierge—beyond even Aurea. Yacht Club is available on most MSC ships but not on some of the smaller and older ships.

Regardless of the experience you choose, you’ll still have access to the pool deck where families can enjoy quality time together. There’s also a dedicated area for the little ones to splash around while the adults can relax and soak up the sun. The kids also have lots to do with clubs, video games, and family-friendly activities available.

On many newer MSC ships, you’ll find full‑size or mini bowling alleys plus other arcade‑style attractions, typically on ships like MSC Grandiosa, Meraviglia‑class and Seaside‑class. Several ships, including MSC Seaview, Seaside, Meraviglia, Preziosa, Divina, Splendida, Fantasia and Magnifica, also feature a 4D Cinema experience with motion seats and special effects.

However, the higher Aurea Experience gives you access to extra perks such as the spa’s Thermal Area, an exclusive sun deck (Top Exclusive Solarium on many ships) and discounted spa treatments.

Key Takeaway:

Carnival Cruises offers a dynamic range of activities for all ages, from the first roller coaster at sea and waterparks to IMAX theaters and live entertainment, ensuring a vibrant and fun-filled experience on board.

In contrast, MSC Cruises sells different “Experiences” that change your perks and inclusions, from standard access to pools, shows and kids’ clubs for all guests through to added benefits on higher tiers, such as spa access, an exclusive sun deck and priority services on Aurea and Yacht Club fares.

Accommodation

When it comes to cabins, both Carnival and MSC have a lot to offer. However, there are some differences worth mentioning:

Carnival Cabins

One of the most striking features of Carnival’s cabins is their generous size. Even the most basic rooms offer plenty of space for passengers to relax and unwind. This is a huge advantage for families or groups, as it allows everyone to have personal space.

Another noteworthy feature is the Family Harbor rooms. These unique rooms are designed with families in mind, offering more beds and extra amenities to make the cruise more comfortable and enjoyable. From comfy bedding to well-appointed bathrooms, the Family Harbor rooms elevate the overall living experience on a Carnival cruise.

Recommended reading: Carnival Suite vs Balcony Staterooms

MSC Cabins

Regarding MSC’s cabins, there are plenty of options, depending on your preferences. Each cabin is designed with comfort and relaxation, ensuring you have everything you need for your voyage. From comfortable beds to spacious bathrooms, each MSC cabin is equipped to make your cruise experience enjoyable.

One of the standout features of MSC cabins is the attention to detail. The crew works tirelessly to maintain the cleanliness and luxury of each cabin. Another notable aspect of MSC cabins is using the latest onboard technology.

On some newer MSC ships, you may find extra tech touches such as an in‑cabin virtual assistant and interactive TV, but availability varies by ship and itinerary.​

Key Takeaways:

Carnival cabins stand out for their generous size and family-focused amenities, particularly in the Family Harbor rooms, making them ideal for families and groups seeking comfort and personal space. MSC cabins, on the other hand, are noted for their attention to detail and technological integration, offering a blend of comfort, luxury, and convenience with features like in-cabin virtual assistants and easy digital navigation, appealing to those who value a modern and seamless cruise experience.

Dining and Drinks

Along with the destination, activities, and cabins are the food and drink. This is definitely one of my top things to consider:

Carnival’s Dining Experience

Carnival is known for its flexible dining options catering to all foodies. The main onboard dining room is notable for its quality and diversity of choices, even for a mass-market ship.

Carnival will also accommodate your dietary needs, whether you prefer vegetarian options or have a gluten-free diet. All restaurants also offer a kid’s menu with great choices for younger members.

Servers at Carnival are known for their efficiency and friendliness. But what sets the dining experience apart is the assistance provided to guests with food allergies. The dining room manager is accommodating and periodically checks in to meet your dietary needs. This attention to detail and care makes the dining experience aboard Carnival exceptional.

MSC’s Dining Experience

MSC offers a diverse range of dining venues aboard their ships. The MSC Seaside, for example, has nine places to eat, four of which are complimentary. With two main dining rooms and two buffets in the cruise fare, there’s plenty of choice for every palate.

However, to experience MSC’s specialty restaurants, you should purchase their dining experience packages. You can buy up to five specialty dining experiences, which will help you save money on expensive menu items. I recommend starting with just one experience until you’ve tried the food at the buffet section.

Key Takeaways:

Carnival’s dining experience is marked by its flexible and diverse options, catering to various dietary needs with a focus on quality, even in its main dining areas. MSC, meanwhile, offers a variety of dining venues, including complimentary and specialty options, with packages available for those wishing to explore their more exclusive culinary experiences.

Comparing Carnival vs MSC

Carnival and MSC are two major lines to consider when planning a cruise. They both have their good reputations and offer something for a wide range of customers. Carnival is known for its lively party atmosphere, while MSC offers a more budget-friendly yet good option.

Both lines have newer ships, like the Carnival Jubilee and the MSC World America with lots of amenities and entertainment options. But, the choice between the two often comes down to individual preferences and the cruise experience you seek.

One thing worth mentioning is the MSC Status Match Program, which is a unique feature belonging to MSC. This stands out because Carnival doesn’t have an official counterpart. What this program does is worth understanding.

In essence, MSC will review your status with another cruise line, hotel or tour operator and then match you to the closest tier in the MSC Voyagers Club. Once approved, you immediately receive at least a 5% discount on future MSC cruises plus the onboard perks associated with your matched MSC tier, but the benefits aren’t an exact copy of what you receive with your original program.

However, choosing between Carnival Cruise Line or MSC Cruises ultimately boils down to personal preference. Consider what you prioritize most during a cruise? Affordability? Luxury? Activities? Diverse dining options? Choose your highest priority first, then this should make your decision a little easier.

You Might Also Like…