Why Loyal Carnival Fans Are Jumping Ship to MSC, And How You Can Too

For years, Carnival cruisers have worn their loyalty badges with pride. Free drinks, priority boarding, and that sweet sense of status, all earned through countless nights at sea. But now, many of those hard-earned perks are sailing off into the sunset.

Carnival’s upcoming overhaul of its loyalty program–which was originally set to launch in June 2026 but was delayed until September 2026, giving cruisers additional time to reach desired status levels–has left loyal guests feeling like they’ve been thrown overboard. The move has sparked frustration and fury across cruise forums, and many longtime fans are eyeing the lifeboats. Enter MSC Cruises, ready and waiting with open arms and a status match program that’s quickly becoming the talk of the ocean.

What’s Changing with Carnival’s Loyalty Program?

Carnival’s current VIFP program rewards cruisers based on the number of nights they’ve spent at sea, a system long seen as fair and straightforward. But from September 1, 2026, that all changes. Instead of rewarding loyalty through time sailed, Carnival will now base status on how much you spend and how often you cruise.

The new program introduces “stars” instead of cruise nights, and tiers will only last for two years unless you keep cruising and spending. That means even the most loyal cruisers could see their status disappear if they take a break. Unsurprisingly, many feel blindsided, especially those who believed their status was for life.

You can find out the details here: Carnival Changing Loyalty Status from Nights at Sea to Amount Spent on Cruises and Credit Card

Why MSC Cruises Is the Big Winner

While Carnival cruisers are still reeling, MSC Cruises has stepped in like a smooth-talking hero with a lifeline: their Status Match program. It’s not new, but it’s suddenly gaining a lot of attention, and for good reason. MSC is offering to honor the loyalty status you earned elsewhere, no questions asked.

For frustrated Carnival fans, this means keeping many of the perks they’ve come to love without starting from scratch. In online forums and Facebook groups, cruisers are encouraging each other to “jump ship” and try MSC instead, and plenty already have. With one simple switch, guests can go from feeling let down to feeling like a VIP again.

What You Get with MSC’s Status Match

MSC’s Status Match isn’t just about recognition, it comes with real perks from your very first sailing. Once approved, you’ll get a 5% discount on all future cruises, plus onboard savings on Wi-Fi, spa treatments, professional photos, and more. You might even receive a complimentary welcome gift.

Crucially, MSC’s loyalty status doesn’t disappear quickly. As long as you cruise once every five years, you’ll keep your tier, a far more generous timeframe than Carnival’s new two-year rule. For many cruisers, that’s the kind of loyalty that feels truly rewarding.

When I went on my first MSC cruise, I took advantage of the status match myself. I’ve been lucky enough to cruise quite a bit with Royal Caribbean, and thanks to my Diamond status, MSC matched me to their Gold tier in the MSC Voyagers Club. Before my sailing, I simply filled out the online form, and it was approved quickly.

As a Gold member, I received a complimentary gift (a drawstring bag), onboard discounts, and even a one-hour thermal spa session. The spa session alone would have cost almost $100, so I was more than happy to take advantage. It was a fantastic perk, featuring two large jacuzzies, multiple saunas and steam rooms, and an ice room.

You can read about my experience here: I Tried One of the Cheapest MSC Euribia Cruises – Here’s What Happened

How to Apply

Signing up for MSC’s Status Match is refreshingly simple. All you need to do is fill out a quick online form on the MSC Cruises website, providing your name, contact details, and proof of your current loyalty status with another cruise line, like Carnival’s VIFP Club.

There’s no fee to apply, and while MSC typically processes status match applications within 3-10 business days, some cruisers report approval within 24 hours. To ensure your benefits apply to your cruise, apply well in advance of your sailing date. Once accepted, your new perks kick in immediately, ready for your next MSC adventure. It’s a hassle-free switch that could save you money and elevate your onboard experience.

Other Cruise Lines Offering Status Matches

MSC may be leading the charge, but it’s not the only cruise line offering a status match. Virgin Voyages, the adults-only line known for its stylish ships and laid-back vibe, is running its own program until March 31, 2026. Successful applicants are bumped up to the Blue Extras tier, which includes perks like complimentary laundry, priority Sailor Services support, and an exclusive cocktail event.

Luxury expedition line Ponant also offers a status match, with immediate discounts on bookings, free laundry, and even onboard credit depending on your tier. While not all cruise lines are jumping on board, the trend is growing, and it’s giving cruisers more options than ever.

Carnival’s Response to the Backlash

Carnival hasn’t ignored the outrage; in fact, it’s quite the opposite. Fleet Cruise Director Lee Mason took to Facebook with a heartfelt message, saying he believed the real loyalty came from shared memories, laughter, and connection between guests and crew. While sincere, it didn’t do much to settle the unrest.

Brand Ambassador John Heald also weighed in, assuring his 600,000+ followers that Carnival still cares and that the new program was announced early to allow room for feedback and possible revisions.

Carnival backed up these words with real changes. In September 2025, the cruise line announced a major enhancement: any guest achieving Diamond status by August 31, 2026 would lock in lifetime Diamond in the new program—a significant win for top-tier loyalists. Platinum members also gained a 10,000-star annual bonus at program launch and every two years thereafter, along with a guarantee of maintaining at least Gold status. These weren’t minor tweaks; they were meaningful responses to genuine concerns, signaling that Carnival values its most dedicated cruisers.

For many cruisers already at Platinum or above, this changes everything. You’re no longer staring at a complete reset of everything you’ve earned. Instead, you get meaningful incentives to stay loyal, including the ultimate prize for Diamond members: lifetime status. While the shift from a nights-based to spend-based system remains a significant change, these enhancements prove Carnival listened and delivered real value for its most committed guests.

Final Word: Is It Time to Jump Ship?

If you’re feeling let down by Carnival’s loyalty overhaul, you’re not alone, and you do have options. MSC’s status match lets you keep enjoying loyalty perks without starting over, and it’s free and easy to apply. For many cruisers, it’s a smart move.

Of course, no cruise line is perfect. But if you’re seeking recognition, onboard discounts, and loyalty perks without starting from scratch, you now have solid options—whether that’s MSC’s status match or Carnival’s enhanced loyalty tiers.

You Might Also Like to Read…