12 Reasons Why You Should Eat at the Cruise Buffet Instead of the Dining Room

For years, cruise traditionalists have sworn by the dining room experience – the white tablecloths, the attentive waiters who somehow remember you prefer your steak medium-rare after just one dinner. That ritual feels special.

But here’s the twist: the buffet (whether it’s called the Windjammer, Lido Marketplace, or Horizon Court) might actually be the smarter choice for most of your cruise meals.

Before you clutch your pearls and declare me a cruise heretic, hear me out. I’m not saying ditch the dining room completely – those lobster nights are sacred.

But there are some compelling reasons why that buffet deserves more love than it gets.

1. It’s WAY Faster

A typical Main Dining Room experience clocks in at 75–90 minutes. That’s an episode of your favorite show plus the commercials. Meanwhile, at the buffet? You can eat well and be out in 15–30 minutes. If you’re on a tight pre-show schedule, that matters.

Picture this. You’ve just explored Rome. Your feet ache. The comedy show starts in 45 minutes. In the dining room, you’ll spend 10 minutes just waiting for bread. At the buffet, you’ll already be halfway through your plate and sipping something cold.

2. The Variety Will Blow Your Mind

The dining room gives you maybe five or six entrées. That’s fine. But the buffet is a rolling food festival. Dozens of options. Multiple cuisines. Seasonal themes. You can build a plate that makes sense for you right now.

Think: Indian curry next to tacos. A pasta station beside an Asian stir-fry counter. Fresh salads with toppings you’ll actually eat. A carving station that smells like Sunday dinner. Breakfast? The omelet crew is fast, friendly, and weirdly gifted at remembering orders.

Not sure what you want? Try a little of everything. You don’t have to commit and hope. You can test and adjust. Picky eaters relax here. Food explorers thrive here. Short answer: more choice equals fewer regrets.

3. Many of the Same Dishes Show Up

Here’s a little secret: a lot of those “fancy” dining room items also appear at the buffet. You’ll often find the same soups, overlapping entrées, and similar desserts. If the dining room is featuring a carved roast or a pasta special, don’t be shocked when a cousin of that dish appears upstairs.

No, it’s not an exact mirror every night. But you’ll recognize a surprising amount. That means you can taste the “specials” without the long sit-down process. If you want the dining room touch – white plates, plated sauce – go there. If you want the flavors fast, the buffet delivers.

Want a quick look at the real-world differences (and similarities) between the two? This short video captures the buffet-versus-dining-room debate nicely:

4. No Dress Code Drama

Formal night can be fun. But some evenings you just don’t have the energy for a blazer or heels. The buffet says: come as you are. Shorts? Fine. Flip-flops? Totally normal. That Hawaiian shirt you bought in port and immediately regretted? Wear it with pride.

One note: most lines ask for shirts and shoes, and they prefer you to be dry. A quick cover-up after the pool does the trick. You’ll be comfortable. You’ll be fast. And you’ll already be mid-bite while everyone else is still wrestling with cufflinks.

5. You Control the Portions

In the dining room, the kitchen decides portion size. At the buffet, you do. Want one spoon of the casserole to test it? Take one spoon. Want extra greens and just a taste of the pasta? Easy. It’s a simple way to eat what you’ll actually enjoy.

This also helps with waste and comfort. Cruise food is tempting. It’s also easy to overdo it. Smaller first portions keep things sane. If something is amazing, go back for a proper serving. If it’s not, you didn’t commit your whole plate.

6. The Drinks Flow Just as Freely

Drink packages work at buffet bars. You can get beer, wine, cocktails, or mocktails without a formal service dance. Self-serve stations handle water, tea, coffee, lemonade, and juices. No waiting around for refills. No trying to flag down the one busy server with a tray of sodas.

7. Those Scenic Ocean Views Though

Many Main Dining Rooms sit away from windows. That’s fine on an interior day. But if you’re gliding past a coastline, you’ll want to see it. The buffet often lives high on the ship with big, panoramic windows. Many even have outdoor seating where the breeze does half the seasoning.

8. Perfect After Port Days Without Waiting Time

Port days are great. They’re also tiring. Sand in your shoes, sunscreen in your hair, and a phone full of photos. The last thing you need is a 90-minute meal and a dress code.

The buffet is the soft landing. Walk in, eat, exhale. If you want to clean up first, do a quick rinse, then head up. It’s casual. It’s calm. It’s exactly enough.

9. Family Dining Without the Kids Drama

Parents, you know the show. Will the kids sit for an hour? Will they like the menu? Will dessert take long enough to spark a meltdown?

The buffet solves this on easy mode. Kids see what they’ll get. There’s almost always pizza, pasta, fruit, and simple proteins. Desserts are immediate. If someone melts down, you can leave without the long, apologetic walk past 200 people.

10. Eat Whenever You Want

Traditional seating at 6:00 and 8:30 is fine if your day is predictable. But cruises aren’t predictable. Excursions run late. Pool time runs long. Trivia runs into karaoke because, well, you’re winning.

The buffet keeps your options open. Early dinner? Done. Post-show bites? Usually yes. Mid-afternoon refuel? Absolutely. Just remember: hours can flex by ship and itinerary, and late-night food might move to a small café or pizza spot. Check the app or daily planner.

11. Your Evening Stays Yours

A quick buffet dinner opens up your night. While others wait on entrées at 7:30, you’re already scanning the theater for great seats. When their dessert hits the table at 8:45, you’re on deck catching that soft glow on the horizon.

Here’s how a smart evening actually plays out without the checklist. Swing by the buffet around 6:30, eat well, and keep it light so you stay energized. By 7:00, you’re in the theater with time to settle, chat, and enjoy the show without staring at your watch.

When the curtain drops, take an easy stroll along the promenade, grab a small dessert you actually want, or slip into trivia if you’re feeling competitive. If there’s a deck party at 10:30, you’ll make it with time to spare – no sprinting, no stress, just the fun parts of the night.

You didn’t chase the night. You owned it.

12. Special Dietary Needs? No Problem

The dining room can handle allergies and restrictions, but it often means a lot of back-and-forth with servers and the kitchen. At the buffet, many items are labeled, and you can see sauces, sides, and preparation styles with your own eyes.

You can ask staff what’s in a dish, confirm ingredients, and choose with confidence. Many ships stock gluten-free bread, dairy-free milk, and real vegetarian or vegan options every day, so you’re not stuck with a plain salad unless you want one.

If you need extra care, go straight to the buffet supervisor or a chef and ask for a quick walkthrough – they’ll point out safe choices and flag anything risky.

Keep an eye on shared tongs and crowded stations, since cross-contamination can happen during busy times; if you’re unsure, request a fresh portion from the back, and they’ll usually make it happen.

Custom stations are your friend because they cook to order; omelets and stir-fry can be done gluten-free, dairy-free, or low-sodium without fuss, and you can watch it all come together right in front of you.

The Bottom Line

Look, I’m not saying abandon the Main Dining Room entirely. Those formal nights have their charm, and yes, having someone remember your name and coffee preference feels pretty special.

But the cruise ship buffet deserves respect. It’s not just about convenience (though that’s huge). It’s about freedom – the freedom to eat what you want, when you want, how you want, dressed however you want.

Whether you’re on Royal Caribbean enjoying the Windjammer Cafe, Carnival’s Lido Marketplace, or Princess Cruises’ Horizon Court buffet, you’re getting way more than just a meal. You’re getting flexibility, variety, and extra time to enjoy everything else your cruise has to offer.

Next time you cruise, give the buffet a real chance. Skip at least a few dining room meals and head upstairs instead. Your schedule (and possibly your waistband) will thank you.

After all, you’re on vacation. Shouldn’t dining feel like it too?

The beauty of cruising is choice. Some nights, dress up and enjoy the dining room pageantry. Other nights? Grab a plate at the buffet in your flip-flops and watch the sunset with a burger in hand.

You Might Also Like This…